Light On Dark Water

Should Dylan Have the Nobel Prize?

For literature? Here's one of many news stories on the announcement that are out this morning.

Much as I love much of his work, I don't really think so. If there were a Nobel Prize for popular music, absolutely yes. But something called "literature" should be able to stand alone on the page, and I don't think his lyrics do. It's almost impossible to read them without hearing them in their musical setting, or at least it is for me. But if I could read his lyrics as pure text on a page I don't think they would make that much of an impression. 

But no doubt there have been less worthy recipients of the prize. 

Maclin Horton
, ,

55 responses to “Should Dylan Have the Nobel Prize?”

  1. Stu

    Hooray for Bob! It’s fun to have a Nobel Prize winner who is a) American, b) I have heard of, and c) I have “read” their work.

    Reply
  2. Mac

    I didn’t realize it had been so long since an American had won.

    Reply
  3. Stu

    Hillary Clinton may win the Nobel Peace Prize next year for keeping Donald Trump from becoming POTUS (sorry for acronym, Janet!).

    Reply
  4. Mac

    That might be more justified than Obama winning it. Actually, though–this is not something I know much about, but I’m hearing a lot of leftish people say that Hillary is a big-time warmonger.

    Reply
  5. Stu

    Mine was a tongue-in-cheek comment, Mac. Just to rile folks up a bit and have them remember Obama’s win.
    That said, I would trust her judgment on anything more than his, except maybe running a reality TV show.

    Reply
  6. Stu

    You may not like her or her politics, but she’s not a friggin lunatic.

    Reply
  7. Marianne

    Everything seems blurred these days, so it’s really not surprising to me that the Nobel folks find that what Dylan’s created is literature.
    Just think about how libraries were once quiet places filled with nothing but books, but are now usually more like community centers, with a little bit of everything going on in them.

    Reply
  8. Paul

    If poetry is “memorable words in cadence” (as another Dylan put it) then I think there’s a fairly strong case to be made.

    Reply
  9. Mac

    Yes, a case, but…without trying to define the word very precisely, I’m willing to grant that Dylan’s work can be considered literature. That said, is it the best American has produced? I can’t see it. Wendell Berry comes immediately to mind as considerably superior. And if we want to judge on poetry alone, there are probably a number of others.
    I really don’t mean this as disparagement of Dylan. It’s basically a question of taxonomy.

    Reply
  10. Charles Kinnaird

    I wasn’t imagining him with the Noble Prize when I wrote this, but this was a poem I wrote about Dylan and his words:
    Dylan the Welder
    Bob Dylan is a welder
    Taking words
    That have been scattered
    Abused
    And misused
    And putting them through the fires
    Of humanity’s forge.
    It takes a hot pen
    To bind mythic thoughts to modern ways;
    And a fiery riff
    To weld common chords to forsaken phrases,
    Fashioning a memorable song of love or theft or ruin.
    It takes a spark that was lit by subterranean fires
    To ignite the passions
    Of a restless generation
    Until they gather on the streets
    Or courthouse lawns
    Or the National Mall
    To sing of how many roads.
    It takes the fire of human consciousness
    Erupting without summons or awareness
    To fashion songs that can
    Shake a tambourine
    Survey a watchtower
    Foretell a hard rain
    Or catch a slow train.
    It takes old embers
    To join hands with
    Woody
    Blind Willie
    Hattie Carroll
    And the sad-eyed lady.
    It takes new fire
    To speak to the hopes of a young woman
    In world that is spinning
    Or the dreams of an old man
    When shadows are falling.
    Bob Dylan is a welder
    Fashioning new gates
    From worn-out words,
    Burning old hopes
    Onto new frames.
    It takes ancient fire
    To fashion timeless tales
    Of joy and struggle,
    And a luminous eye
    To forge a song that is true.
    ~ Charles Kinnaird
    http://notdarkyet-commentary.blogspot.com/2013/11/dylan-welder.html

    Reply
  11. Mac

    Nice. And in case anyone is not aware of it, Dylan is an actual welder, i.e. with torch and metal. There’s a picture at Charles’s blog:
    http://notdarkyet-commentary.blogspot.com/2016/10/bob-dylan-nobel-laureate.html

    Reply
  12. Stu

    Wendell Berry would be suitable obscure. I had never heard of him until reading this blog. I’ve been in the camp of rooting for Philip Roth for many years.

    Reply
  13. Mac

    Hmm, I don’t think of Berry as being all that obscure. He’s pretty much of an all-round player: novels, poetry, essays.
    I read a long excerpt from Portnoy’s Complaint in an anthology when I was in college. It left with me with an aversion to Roth and I’ve never read another word by him.

    Reply
  14. Stu

    Now I have to run to Roth’s defense! It’s sort of like early Woody Allen was slapstick and juvenile, and late (or maybe mid) Woody became more thoughtful and grown up? Portnoy is very slapstick, sexual, and silly. Almost all of his other books are way less so; not that they steer completely away from sexuality, but it does become more adult.
    Woody Allen is to Philip Roth, as Frank Zappa is to Kurt Vonnegut, as Tom Waits is to Charles Bukowski.
    Or something like that…

    Reply
  15. Stu

    I had never heard of Flannery O’Connor or Walker Percy until I had to read them at Spring Hill College. Neither is very interesting to me, but you all love them!

    Reply
  16. Mac

    That’s genuinely surprising. I mean not that you don’t find them interesting, we all have our individual tastes, but that you had never heard of them. Especially O’Connor, who I think is regarded by critics as one of the very best short story writers.
    I might like Zappa better than Vonnegut, and I’m pretty sure I like Waits better than Bukowski, based on slight acquaintance with Bukowski. So maybe I would like Allen better than Roth.

    Reply
  17. Stu

    I don’t really find short stories interesting is probably my issue with O’Connor. I’ve read both of her novels, and they were okay, but nothing too memorable except the protagonist of Wise Blood seemed “special needs”.
    I feel bad saying any of that. A friend of mine just finished Anna Karenina and gave me a decidedly “meh” review. I could really just read the different translations of AK over and over again and be satisfied for a long time.
    I already knew that you preferred music to modern lit, Mac.

    Reply
  18. Marianne

    I was fortunate to be in college before Portnoy and instead was introduced to Roth by his Goodbye, Columbus book. Don’t remember a lot about it, except that it was very funny, and with a comparatively buttoned-down approach to sex. Never read Portnoy, just the reviews of it, but they were enough to keep me away from the rest of his books.

    Reply
  19. Mac

    When I read that Portnoy excerpt I had no objection at all to the sexual content as such. But it was just sort of…gross. Ugly.

    Reply
  20. Grumpy

    Bob Dylan has not responded to the Nobel Committee
    Maybe he has his own view

    Reply
  21. Mac

    I saw that somewhere earlier and just laughed: a perfect reaction from him. Made me think of what a friend of mine said about him back ca 1970 or so, quoting one of Dylan’s own songs: “He was never known to make a foolish move.” Of course he later made quite a few, but still…

    Reply
  22. Janet

    I wish I’d know this conversation had gotten a bit off-track. 😉
    I read Portnoy when I was about 18, and it was eye-opening in a really terrible way. I’m not sure which passage you are referring to, but there are two really gross passages that I wish that I could expunge from my mind forever. I know there were more, but I remember these two very well.
    It is odd to have not heard of O’Connor because A Good Man is Hard to Find is pretty routinely in Am. Lit textbooks.
    AMDG

    Reply
  23. Mac

    It wasn’t any passage in particular in Portnoy, just the whole spirit of the thing. Seems kind of sad for an 18-year-old girl to have read it. But that was then–now stuff that crude is everywhere.

    Reply
  24. Stu

    I don’t remember reading any Southern Literature at all until Absalom, Absalom! in college (which is one of my favorite books). I grew up in Miami, which is below the South, and perhaps they ignore the South down there? But then went to college in Missouri (above the South) but finished my degree back in Miami which is where I read the Faulkner book.

    Reply
  25. Mac

    I have occasionally enjoyed starting arguments by stating that Faulkner is overrated.

    Reply
  26. Stu

    Well, he is, but that doesn’t make him bad! 🙂

    Reply
  27. Janet

    Maclin, You said, “When I read that Portnoy excerpt,” so I was assuming you had only read one. 😉
    That was one of the first things that I read or looked at that I am supremely sorry to have in my head. For some reason, his stuff has been extremely hard to get rid of.
    AMDG

    Reply
  28. Mac

    It was a long excerpt, several chapters at least. Enough to give a very good sense of the book.
    By no means do I think Faulkner is bad. Just not quite the giant he’s considered.

    Reply
  29. Stu

    Okay I’m going to have to re-read Portnoy after all of this bitterness towards it! 🙂 I remember laughing myself crazy; of course I was a teen-age boy when I read it for the one and only time. I will probably find it very tame compared to what is out there these days.

    Reply
  30. Stu

    Dylan is like the anti-Trump. Just in personality, nothing to do with his politics which I am not even aware of and he probably hasn’t shared. Part of what makes him an anti- Some people respond to everything, and others to nothing.

    Reply
  31. Marianne

    Dylan is nothing if not enigmatic, I guess. He’s still not responded to the Nobel folks about receiving the prize — Nobel panel gives up knockin’ on Dylan’s door

    Reply
  32. Mac

    Yeah, it’s hilarious. From “Changing of the Guard, on the Street Legal album:
    “Gentlemen,” he said, “I don’t need your organization.”
    As for Trump and his “responding,” he seems to be unable to resist lashing out a any attack on his wealth and business skill. Very easily baited. Must be fun for the Dems/media.

    Reply
  33. Grumpy

    https://theguard1an.com/breaking-news-bob-dylan-rejects-nobel-laureates-accolade/

    Reply
  34. Grumpy

    Im glad he did that. A troubadour cannot have the Nobel prize for literature. it would mess with his inspiration

    Reply
  35. Grumpy

    I just figured out that that story comes from a fake news site. I looked at the Guardian to see the story in context and it’s not there. So I looked at the site itself and it’s not the Guardian if you look closely. Its a fake site

    Reply
  36. Mac

    Yeah I noticed that the i is actually a numeral 1, but couldn’t figure out whether it was a joke site or not. Anyway I’m sorry it’s not true. Assuming it really isn’t.

    Reply
  37. Janet

    Well, you know, ignoring it is a larger statement than rejecting it.
    AMDG

    Reply
  38. Mac

    Maybe so.

    Reply
  39. Grumpy

    I went back and tried to find the person Who shared the story on fb and they dont exist. Its a ghost site with a name very slightly different from a real fbf

    Reply
  40. Mac

    That is a very weird site. Looks like just a junk clickbait thing but it’s also a bit funny. From the About Us page:
    “You are on this website because we believe you have the eyes to see the number one in our name…. By reading from this website you accept that the world was created by the U.S. President Barack Obama.”
    Hope it isn’t doing something bad to my computer.

    Reply
  41. Grumpy

    So do I! Im in jerusalem and all Ive got is my phone. Ive been paying bills from my phone etc

    Reply
  42. Mac

    iPhone? I sorta have the impression that they’re less vulnerable to that kind of thing that Androids, or Windows PCs (what I looked at that site with).

    Reply
  43. Grumpy

    Yes its an iphone!

    Reply
  44. Grumpy

    I dont consider Dylan unworthy to win but it seems to spoil pop music if it becomes official piublic art

    Reply
  45. Mac

    I basically think it’s sort of silly, although it’s not the first silly Nobel (probably nothing will ever match Obama’s Peace Prize in that respect). Much as I like Dylan, I think this over-praises him. It’s almost kind of patronizing. I suppose the members of the Academy are baby-boomers who haven’t entirely gotten over themselves (as a generation) yet.

    Reply
  46. Mac

    Three out of five. And one of the others is Dylan’s age.
    http://nobelpeaceprize.org/en_GB/nomination_intro/members/

    Reply
  47. Janet

    You know, you would think if they gave you the Nobel Peace Prize for doing nothing, you would try to live up to it in some way.
    AMDG

    Reply
  48. Mac

    On the other hand, if you’ve already got it…

    Reply
  49. Marianne

    I didn’t see the name of the woman who made the announcement about Dylan, Sara Danius, in that list, Mac. It seems it’s the Swedish Academy that handles the Nobel Prize in Literature. Danius is the one who compared Dylan to Homer and Sappho. In any case, she was born in 1962, so a baby boomer, though close to the end of the boomer generation birth years.

    Reply
  50. Mac

    Oh yeah, I see now that the page I was looking at is specific to the Peace Prize. Yep, 1962 is pretty close.
    I think there’s a fallacy in that Homer/Sappho comparison. I mean, if the point is that their work was sung, that’s not really relevant, because it hasn’t been heard that way for a couple of thousand years or more, and it’s survived because it’s great as written words alone. I just don’t think Dylan’s would, if his recordings were lost. It would be interesting to check back 200 years from now and see how he’s regarded. Or if he’s remembered at all. My suspicion is that most of his appeal will not greatly outlast its time. But who knows?

    Reply
  51. Stu

    After Mac & Janet discussed their collective hatred of Portnoy’s Complaint I decided I should re-read it. I had only read it as a teen-ager and loved it. I’m happy to report that reading it as a 50 year old is much the same experience. Sorry, I don’t find any of these things icky, disgusting, overtly sexual, etc. I just find them to be part of the human experience, especially if you ever have been an adolescent male. The larger surprise is that so much of the book is not that way at all, since my memory was very much centered on the early masturbation section. Roth remains a very worthy American candidate for the Nobel prize in literature. I’ve been re-reading a lot of his stuff this year, and reading some of the later short novels as well. Everything by him is somewhat worthwhile, even The Breast!

    Reply
  52. Mac

    The “early masturbation section” is apparently what was printed in that magazine. Just seemed kind of gross, like Ignatius in Confederacy of Dunces (a book I did think was hilarious, mostly). I remember a couple of bits that were certainly “overtly sexual” to say the least, although they didn’t go into a lot of detail, so maybe that’s what you mean?

    Reply
  53. Stu

    I’m not sure what I mean since it really is overtly sexual … at least that section. Perhaps I was saying that printed matter of overtly sexual material is not offensive to me; at least not within the context of what I would consider good writing. I have not read Fifty Shades of Grey….not entirely sure what it is even about. But there is “erotica” and then books that have episodes which are sexually charged. What I look for in literature are representations of the human experience I can relate to. Why I have such trouble with: Dan Brown, Robert Ludlum, et al

    Reply
  54. Mac

    It wasn’t “offensive” exactly. I mean I had no moral objection at all to it. Just …well, like I said, kind of gross.

    Reply
  55. Janet

    Either I’m remembering another book or y’all are crazy.
    AMDG

    Reply

Leave a comment

Instagram / TikTok / X

Designed with WordPress