Sling Blade

The local paper has a feature called "Today In History" or something like that, which notes significant events that have occurred on this date. August 4, for instance, was the date of: the murder of Lizzie Borden's parents in 1892, the declaration of war by Britain in 1914, and the arrest of Anne Frank and her family in 1944. It also happens to be the birthday of Billy Bob Thornton, and so a good day to recommend this movie, in which he gives a really remarkable performance.

I had heard that Sling Blade was a good movie, but had the mistaken idea that it was some sort of semi-horror thing, and very violent. Rob G corrected that misunderstanding in a comment here a couple of months (?) or so ago, and since his recommendations are usually good I decided to take this one. The movie begins with an account of a murder committed with the implement named in the title–a sort of scythe, and not the same thing I knew as a "sling" or "swing" blade when I was growing up. But there is no explicit violence. 

The story concerns Karl Childers, whom we meet as a patient in a mental hospital. He is clearly not right in the head. He's frequently described by others as "retarded," but his problem strikes me as something closer to a form of autism. At any rate, he has been committed to the insitution because he committed two murders, and presumably found not guilty by reason of insanity. I'm not giving away too much with that, because we learn it in the first ten minutes or so of the film. Karl has been declared to be cured, and is released. He returns to the small town of his childhood, and soon makes friends with a boy and his single mother. 

And that's enough synopsis. We are deep in southern gothic territory here, which of course overlaps with Flannery O'Connor territory, and while this is not quite an O'Connor-class story it's good enough to be worth watching more than once. It's not easy to watch; it's full of painful and then menacing situations. But it's difficult to stop watching, too; the story takes hold of you. I was not altogether happy with the ending when I saw it, but after living with it for a few days I changed my mind.

Billy Bob Thornton's portrayal of Karl is remarkable, to say the least, and probably the most immediately striking thing about the movie. I was surprised and very impressed when the credits rolled at the end, informing me that Thornton also wrote and directed it. I had been familiar with his name as an interesting actor whom I'd seen in only a few roles, mostly small, and as part of a celebrity couple of which the other half was Angelina Jolie. But forget all that publicity and gossip: the man is an artist.

Here's a clip which will give you an idea of the character of Karl. He has just returned to his home town.

 

The scene at the laundromat which closes this clip is where he meets the boy, Frank Wheatley. (Frank is played by the young Lucas Black, now an adult actor who played the younger funeral parlor employee, Buddy Robinson, in Get Low.)

The version I saw–the one Netflix sent me–is two and a half hours long. I gather from the commentary on the DVD, of which I only heard a few minutes, that it includes some scenes that were cut from the original release. Not having seen the other, I can't compare them, but although it's pretty slow-moving in the longer version I don't think much was wasted, and you might be missing some good stuff if you see the shorter one. 

Oh, and by the way: the soundtrack is by Daniel Lanois and consists mostly of his beautiful atmospheric guitar work. It's probably worth buying.

47 responses to “Sling Blade

  1. Terrific movie. I saw it several years ago but still remember it quite well, which is more than I can say for most.

  2. I watched about 15 minutes of this last night and then I had to go to bed. I hope it gets easier to watch. I think it probably will.
    AMDG

  3. You don’t really miss much by seeing the shorter theatrical version — I think it’s a 13 minute difference and those 13 minutes aren’t vital.
    Sling Blade is one of my two or three favorite movies of the 90’s, and is an all-time fave of mine. I’ve watched it quite a few times, and each time I find it powerful and very moving, esp. the scenes where Karl talks with Frank about his baby brother (the “little feller”) and where Karl confronts his father.

  4. I think Karl’s monologue at the beginning, the scene in which he tells the girl reporter the story of why he’s in the mental hospital, is truly an outstanding piece of acting.

  5. Agree with both of your comments, Rob. I can see this being a favorite of mine. I definitely want to see it again. I would say more but I want to avoid spoilers.
    I don’t know that it gets any easier, Janet. I guess it gets easier, then harder.

  6. I watched the trailer and immediately ordered it.

  7. I think you’ll like it.
    By the way, just for the record: I can be a little prickly about negative (or for that matter positive) stereotyping of southerners, but although this movie does support some of those, I don’t think it’s at all inaccurate or unfair. Like cliches, stereotypes exist for a reason. Billy Bob Thornton grew up in Arkansas, very similar culturally to my home.

  8. Noah G.

    Yeah, great movie. After I saw first saw it at the theaters I went around talking like him for a day or two, annoying the heck out of my family.
    I’ve always thought that Dwight Yoakam should have been nominated (along with Billy Bob, who got a best actor nomination). Such a great performance, still one of my favorite movie villains.

  9. Just speaking of movies, I’d like to thank Marianne (I think it was) who recommended Broadyway Danny Rose for my ‘Love’ course. I watched it over the weekend and am definitely using it on the course.

  10. The thing about DY’s performance is that it doesn’t even seem like a performance to me. I mean, not that I think Dwight is Doyle, but that Doyle seems so absolutely real to me, so much like people I’ve actually met, that the line really blurs. Not that anyone I’ve ever known was that bad, but the basic personality, way of talking, way of ordering his girlfriend around, the mean streak…everything. Good as BBT’s portrayal is, I still found myself thinking “what great acting”.

  11. Noah G.

    Yeah, I definitely agree. He’s actually been typecast a bit, I’m pretty sure as a result of that role. As a side note, I love his music too now, though I didn’t used to at all.

  12. I’ve never heard much of his music but now I’m interested. I have a friend who likes him and is not in general a fan of standard country-pop (neither am I).

  13. It is precisely what you say about Doyle that makes it so difficult for me to watch. I don’t know how any woman can stand to listen to and watch that. He’s just too much like certain men that I can’t bear to be in a room with. They are so menacing in a creepy kind of way. Ugh. When, very occasionally, one comes to my door at work, it’s everything I can do to keep from slamming the door in their faces.
    I agree with what you say about Karl’s monologue. That is painful to watch, but well done and I can take that.
    AMDG

  14. Dwight’s music is not typical country-pop. He’s got more in common with older style country singers like Buck Owens and Roger Miller (in his more serious moments.) I don’t like Yoakam’s honky-tonk stuff so much, but I have two of his albums that are a lot of fun: ‘This Time’ and ‘Gone.’

  15. I was never especially a fan of the Buck Owens-era of country, either. Don’t dislike it, like I do current pop-country, it just doesn’t much appeal to me. I’ll give Yoakam a listen on Rdio, though.

  16. Yeah, Janet, I think we both can see him as a recognizable southern type, unfortunately. And he’s sort of a sub-type who’s basically weak but can feel like a man by pushing women and children around.

  17. Noah G.

    This was the first album I heard of his, the one that hooked me: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kZ2ucSWD7Cw
    I love that he writes (and writes well as it turns out) most or all of his own songs, which seems rare with popular country artists. Anyway, it’s very country, you have to be able to stand the slide guitars and all that. (I used to absolutely hate slide guitars, now I can’t get enough of ’em.)

  18. That’s good, but it doesn’t hit me as something I’d like to hear a lot more of. I don’t dislike the pedal steel although it’s not my favorite instrument, either. I think what it finally comes down to for me is the writing. That’s a good song of its type, but the type is not one that I have a lot of enthusiasm for.

  19. Noah G.

    I think I know what you mean. Not to sound like a broken record, but I used to (used to this, used to that) really hate this type. I don’t know what happened. Now it’s honestly all I want to listen to.

  20. That’s an interesting change. What were you changing from? I never hated this kind of music, it just wasn’t/isn’t something I seek out. I do hate some of the current pop-country, but that’s probably a song-by-song thing. I can’t offhand name anything current that I either like or don’t. I know I really hate the “here we are, us good old boys and girls, drinking beer and dancing in the moonlight down by the ol’ creek having driven here from the ol’ barn in the ol’ pickup truck and bein’ just as dadgum real and authentic as this ol’ pickup and that ol’ barn, infinitely more authentic than them ol’ city people” stuff–anything that paints that asinine picture of rural life that has nothing to do with the way either the artists or the listeners live, not to mention reality. Like a friend of mine said on Facebook, it would be more genuine if they talked about meth and unemployment. And I hate the stuff that’s just party anthems with a fiddle and a twang in the voice.
    All of which adds up to “I never willingly listen to contemporary country” 🙂 so although there’s surely some good stuff out there, I don’t hear it.

  21. My favorite Dwight song is “A Thousand Miles From Nowhere,” which I first heard on the soundtrack to the film ‘Red Rock West.’ It leans a bit more towards rock than most of his stuff, but still has that twang. For awhile in the mid to late 90s I was listening to a lot of “alt country” stuff, some of which I still like a lot. That tune fit right in.

  22. Noah G.

    Ha!, that’s a really good characterization of a lot of the radio country these days, I definitely can’t stand that stuff either. Right now I’m mostly listening to Alan Jackson, George Strait, Dwight Yoakam, and George Jones, that’s what’s been running on my ipod…and a number of good (or tolerable) country songs from random people that I hear on the radio.
    I changed from listening to Jane’s Addiction, Red Hot Chili Peppers, Fugazi, Butthole Surfers, basically a lot of punk and what was called “alternative” back in the nineties, and also a lot of Hip-Hop. And then a little later some old Jazz, Swing, etc., and some Blues… There was a point where, when asked, I just started saying “a little of everything…except country.”
    And now: nothing but Country. And a little Gospel.
    Maybe it’s a phase (I tend to go through music phases), but if it is it sure has lasted a dern long time. !

  23. ‘Thousand Miles’ features some really good guitar work from Yoakam’s long-time collaborator Pete Anderson.

  24. Thanks to my local library, I’ve been listening to most of Dwight Yoakam’s records over the past few months. He definitely doesn’t fit the “contemporary country” model — he has a greater stylistic range and a less commercial focus, for sure — but unfortunately I find he has relatively few songs that I actually enjoy hearing. Somehow the songwriting is too generic, as though he were writing good imitations of good country songs, rather than actually just writing good country songs. And there is a nasal quality to his voice that I find unappealing. There is one song, though, that I really like: “Try Not to Look So Pretty”. There is a “music video” for it; I don’t link to it because it practically destroys the song.
    I have seen Sling Blade, but it was years ago, when I was but knee-high to a grasshopper, and I don’t remember much of anything about it. Perhaps I should see it again. For now, though, I think I’ll take this cold beer and head on down to the ol’ crick in my ol’ pickup and see how the ol’ boys are doing.

  25. Here is a ‘video’ of “Try Not to Look so Pretty” that is not the terrible music video that wrecks the song.

  26. I’ll have to wait till later to watch those videos.
    I’ve never heard much hip-hop/rap that I liked. But the one reasonably identifiable style of music that I really have zero use for is smooth jazz.

  27. Really like Thousand Miles!

  28. I like both of those ok, but…again, just not enthusiastic. I did notice the guitar on Thousand Miles and also No Such Thing, Rob. I always notice the guitar. Excellent.
    Of your alternative/punk list, Noah, I haven’t heard much. I actively dislike the Chili Peppers, to the extent I’ve heard them, but it’s more the vibe I get from them than the music itself. Excellent musicianship, but the result is unappealing to me.

  29. I’ve been known to sing Thousand Miles at karaoke. Also, his ‘Fast as You.’

  30. You must be a pretty good singer, and very bold. I can’t imagine doing that.

  31. Noah G.

    The Chili Peppers used to be one of my favorites in the early nineties, when they were more of a funk/punk/rock hybrid (I wouldn’t know how to characterize them now). They were a band for adolescents though, in my opinion, and the others I mentioned as well. i.e. you’re not missing much. 🙂 (I should say non-Christian adolescents–really really explicit)

  32. Yeah, that was pretty much my impression.

  33. Marianne

    So glad you like Broadway Danny Rose, Grumpy. I’ve mentioned the movie to others over the years, but always get an oh, no, not a Woody Allen movie response. But Danny Rose is not at all his typical kind of character, is he?
    Re Sling blade: Sort of embarrassed to say that I’ve avoided watching it because of Billy Bob Thornton. And that simply because I once saw an interview of him and his then-wife Angelina Jolie during which they shared with viewers their tattoos and capsules of one another’s blood they wore around their necks. Have never been able to look at either of them since without thinking of that. But that clip makes me think it’s time for me to grow up and watch it.

  34. Hmm, I managed to miss the second part of this comment last night. I had heard some of that stuff, too, though happily didn’t have to listen to them talk about it. As a person, I don’t know about BBT. And I don’t know whether he’s done anything else nearly as good as this. But this is good. Like I said, though, it’s not easy to watch.

  35. Invited a grad student to lunch – he set up my new huge DVD screen, ate lunch, and watched Sling Blade. He thinks it will be good for 2nd year students. So the test drive worked!
    He doesn’t agree with my interpretation of Karl, but that’s cool too. Noone else will either!

  36. So, what’s your interpretation of Karl?
    I can do a pretty good imitation of Karl’s way of speaking. This morning I startled my wife and got a big laugh out of her with it.

  37. grumphy

    I think the movie could be read as presenting Karl as a supernatural figure. He is outside the realm of moral judgment, like an avenging angel or guardian angel.
    When I put this to him, the grad student and I discussed whether the movie presents Karl and the gay guy as equivalent outsider figures. He conceded that the movie puts Karl as thinking he is an interesting outsider, but really slightly dull and having found a way of living in the small town. So the movie doesn’t make the two equivalent.
    But the grad student, who is an English major, who did a theology MTs to improve his understanding of literature, thought it was overly theological to find a guardian angel actually inside the movie’s intentions.

  38. Well, that’s really not far off from the way I see him. I wasn’t thinking supernatural in himself, but something like a divinely-directed warrior or instrument of justice. Not guilty in the way that an ordinary person would be (talking about the final incident here), because his intentions are truly pure.
    I would probably more or less agree with your grad student that a systematic and more or less orthodox theology is not consciously intended, but a lot of it works out pretty close to that.

  39. grumphy

    that’s what I think – I would he happy to say a divinely directed warrior. like an angel who appears at some OT character’s side

  40. grumphy

    I meant to say that the movie presents the gay guy as actually not an outsider – I wrote ‘Karl’! Major typo..

  41. Ah! I was having trouble figuring out what that meant. I agree, I don’t think Karl and the gay guy (Vince?) are equivalent in that sense.

  42. grumphy

    I meant, the grad student thought a problem with my interpretion could be that the gay guy and Karl are both presented as outsider figures. So I argued, and he agreed, that they are not equivalent outside figures. The gay guy thinks he’s an outsider, but he actually has negotiated a way of living in the small town. Karl seems to have found acceptance in the small town, but actually he cannot fit there, it is ‘too big’ for him.

  43. ~~Spoiler alert~~~
    I find the scene where Karl confronts his father tremendously moving — the part where he tells him that he ought not to have let his baby brother die like that. “He shoulda had a chance to grow up. He woulda had fun sometimes.”
    It’s like a profound pro-life statement coming from the mouth of a little kid.

  44. grumphy

    It’s a great scene. I had forgotten you guys said Robert Duvall was in it, and when he appears, suddenly, as the father, it, and he, are wonderful. Watching it the 2nd time this weekend, I realized Karl tries to go home immediately on leaving the ‘nervous hospital’, but can’t cross that bridge.

  45. Duvall’s appearance in Sling Blade had something to do with BBT’s appearance in The Apostle. They did them as favors for each other or something like that — don’t remember the details.

  46. Right, I agree with you, grumphy about Karl vs. the gay guy, as regards their outsider status–Karl is in a different league in that respect, so to speak.
    I was surprised to see Duvall, too. I was surprised at that whole scene, actually. Somehow I had gotten the impression that Karl’s family were all gone–died or moved away. And I agree about that scene–“he woulda had fun sometimes” is unbearably poignant.

Leave a reply to grumphy Cancel reply