Andy Weir: Project Hail Mary

Andy Weir is the author of The Martian, which I have not read. But I have seen the movie of the same name which was based on the book, and quite enjoyed it. The title character is not a sentient extraterrestrial alien being, but rather one of us, stranded alone on Mars when the mission of which he was a part gets into big trouble and the other members, believing him to be dead, return to earth without him. The book is the story of his very clever and resourceful efforts to survive and get himself rescued, and the movie at any rate was pretty enjoyable. 

I would most likely not have read this book, either, in the ordinary course of things, but I've had occasion to run up and down the length of Alabama on I-65 twice in the past few weeks, and listened to the fourteen-hour audio version. I would recommend it to anyone who enjoyed The Martian, book or film, and especially to anyone who likes what's called "hard" science fiction.

Back in my teens when I read almost exclusively science fiction, that term was used to describe science fiction which is solidly based on scientific fact and theoretically plausible technology. Having written that sentence, I wondered whether the term is still in use, and it is: there's a Wikipedia entry for it. The other kind of science fiction, the not-so-hard kind, can be represented by Ray Bradbury's The Martian Chronicles, which, according to my recollection of it from sixty years ago, doesn't go to a lot of trouble to justify scientifically or technologically its depiction of a Martian colony, or its relations with that planet's indigenous Martians, but is more concerned with its cultural and political aspects. 

Project Hail Mary is also distinctly hard sci-fi, and it's not unfair to describe it as a much higher stakes version of the same basic story line: there is an even more dire and extensive problem and the scientific and technological efforts to solve it are extreme. (The title, in case you don't know, refers to the "Hail Mary pass," a desperate last-second move in a football game, a long pass that's unlikely to be caught: say a prayer and throw the ball.) The problem–The Problem–is that the world is coming to an end, or at least coming to an end for a great deal of life on earth, because the sun is rapidly cooling.

And I'm not going to say much more about the plot than that, because even the scientific work involved in discovering the nature of The Problem is fascinating, and I don't want to give even that much away, much less describe the development of a just-barely-not-hopeless attempt–Project Hail Mary–at solving it, and how that plan works out. Most of the story, told in a very effective combination of flashbacks and current events, involves the narrator, Ryland Grace, a one-time molecular biologist now teaching middle-school science. I suppose it might be the fantasy of many very small-time scientists to make a discovery that will Save The World; Grace not only makes significant discoveries, but is very closely involved in implementing the project, with a resourcefulness at least equal to that of the Martian.

Mark Twain once said something like "I love work. I can sit and look at it for hours." My relationship to science is somewhat like that. I'm fascinated by the Big Picture provided by science, but not much interested in delving deeply into its complexity. This book provides just enough actual scientific information and thinking that I can enjoy the weaving of scientific fact and technological imagination into a story that kept my interest.  

This is not great literature, but I found it fascinating, at least for the first ten or eleven hours; there came a point when the encounter with yet another major problem and yet another wild attempt to solve it became just a bit tiresome. I do have some reservations about the plausibility of several features and plot developments, but I can't discuss those, either, without giving away more of the plot than I want to. 

Project_Hail_Mary _First_Edition_Cover_(2021)

This image does have a connection to the actual events of the novel. However, don't let it mislead you into thinking that the solution to The Problem involves lowering Ryland Grace into the sun. That would really be implausible.


13 responses to “Andy Weir: Project Hail Mary

  1. I too enjoyed the movie The Martian, and also have not read the book. Looks like the Project Hail Mary film has already been made and will be released in March. Could be good:
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Hail_Mary_(film)

  2. It could be A good movie, but they will have to cut out a lot to get it into two or three hours. I guess they’ll just have to gloss over a lot of details.

  3. Anne-Marie

    This sounds like a perfect present for my son who loved The Martian (both the movie and the book).

  4. That sounds like a very good bet. As I say that I’m wondering if the reading I listened to made a difference. It’s pretty persuasive as the voice of a contemporary thirty-something guy. Reading on the other hand would give one the opportunity to easily go back over some of the complicated bits of physics and engineering.

  5. Speaking of s/f, I’m reminded that a science fiction novel, ‘Orbital’ by Samantha Harvey, won the Booker Prize last year. I have it on my list but haven’t read it yet.

  6. Well, that’s an odd thing. Must be a somewhat unusual kind of sci-fi.

  7. Yes — per wikipedia: “The novel, told over the course of 24 hours, follows six astronauts and cosmonauts from Japan, the United States, Britain, Italy, and Russia, four men and two women, aboard the International Space Station as they orbit Earth. In addition to detailing the official duties and tasks of the astronauts aboard the spacecraft, the novel also features their reflections about humanity and subjects including the existence or nature of God, the meaning of life, and existential threats such as climate change.”
    To me it seems like the type of thing that could be either quite good or really bad, depending upon one’s perspective on the issues at hand and on the quality of the writing. Thing is, it’s only 136 pp., the second shortest book ever to win the Booker, so it would not require a huge outlay of time/effort to find out.

  8. “…could be either quite good or really bad”–agreed. Calling climate change an existential threat is not a good sign but then that’s Wikipedia, not the author (I assume).
    Made me think of the first Space Odyssey section in Walker Percy’s Lost in the Cosmos. In fact it made me go get the book and look at that bit, which is still hilarious. The final message from the peaceful planet on which the desperate earthlings want to land: “Good luck. You have one hour to vacate orbit. Over and out.”

  9. “Calling climate change an existential threat is not a good sign but then that’s Wikipedia, not the author (I assume).”
    I thought exactly the same thing. I may get the book from the library and read it next. It would make a bit of a break for me from what I normally read fiction-wise.
    “Good luck…” — LOL. Love that book.

  10. Have you read “Stories of Your Life,” the novella by Ted Chiang that the movie Arrival was based on? I may give that one a shot as well.

  11. No. I remember it being mentioned when the movie came out and thinking that it might be worth reading, but never did anything about it. Actually I had forgotten about it, so I’m glad you mentioned it. Unfortunately I looked just now and my local library doesn’t have anything by him.

  12. The Chiang book came in from the library yesterday and ‘Orbital’ should show up today or tomorrow. I’ll likely read the latter first and will report in due course.

  13. Very good. I’ll be interested in hearing your reaction.

Leave a reply to Mac Cancel reply